Best Fireplace Inserts: Picks and What to Look For

The best fireplace insert depends on fuel and goals: a wood insert from makers such as Regency, Lopi or Enviro suits homeowners who want real heat and have a way to store and season firewood, a gas insert from makers such as Napoleon or Heat and Glo suits people who want push-button convenience, and an electric insert suits those who want ambience with no chimney work. Inserts must be sized to the existing firebox, and installation affects safety, so treat this guide as a starting point and rely on the maker’s manual, local code and a certified installer.

Our top picks

Top pickGiantex 28.5" Electric Fireplace Insert

Check price on Amazon

Also greatInnoflame 23" Electric Fireplace Insert

Check price on Amazon

Also greatPuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire

Check price on Amazon

Also great50 inch Electric Fireplace Recessed and Wall

Check price on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Fireplace Inserts at a Glance

Understanding the Fuel Choices

Wood inserts

A wood insert fits into an existing masonry fireplace and burns more efficiently than an open hearth, because the closed firebox and glass door control air and recover heat with a blower. Makers such as Regency, Lopi and Enviro publish heat output ranges, burn times and emissions ratings for specific models. Choose a unit certified by a recognized emissions standard, and plan on dry, seasoned hardwood. The trade-off is labor: you haul, stack, load and clean out ash, and you must schedule annual chimney inspection and cleaning.

Gas inserts

Gas inserts use a sealed combustion system, often vented through a liner, and respond to a remote or wall switch. Napoleon and other makers offer models with different flame styles and optional thermostats. They suit households that want warmth on demand without handling wood. They still produce combustion gases, so they must be vented as the manual specifies, and a carbon monoxide alarm should be installed nearby. Gas line work and venting belong with a licensed installer.

Pellet inserts

Pellet units feed compressed wood pellets automatically, giving consistent heat with less mess than logs. They need electricity for the auger and fan, so they stop during a power cut unless you have a backup supply. Regular cleaning of the burn pot and ash is required.

Electric inserts

Electric inserts plug into an outlet and display a flame effect with an optional space-heater function. They are the simplest to install and need no venting, but they only add modest supplementary heat. Follow the maker’s electrical requirements, and do not use extension cords with heating products.

Sizing and Fit

An insert must match your existing firebox. Measure the opening width at the front and back, the height, and the depth, and compare with the model’s required dimensions. Many makers publish a minimum opening size and supply surround panels or trim kits to cover gaps. Also consider hearth extension, clearances to combustible mantels and flooring, and chimney height. Oversizing a wood or gas insert for a small room can cause overheating, while undersizing wastes the investment. A certified installer can perform a chimney inspection and a heat-load estimate.

Heat Output, Efficiency and Blower

Makers list output in BTUs and a heating-area estimate; treat these as best-case figures. Efficiency ratings for wood and pellet units come from lab methods, while gas units list fireplace efficiency. A blower moves warm air into the room, which improves actual usable heat but adds noise. Reviewers frequently mention that glass door cleanliness, flame view and ease of loading differ between models, so view a showroom model if you can.

Safety and Installation

• Use a certified installer; a stainless liner from the insert to the chimney top is typically required for wood and gas units.
• Obtain permits and inspections where local code requires.
• Install working smoke and carbon monoxide alarms on each level.
• Keep combustibles away from the unit by the clearance listed in the manual.
• Do not burn trash, treated lumber or unseasoned wood.
• Have the chimney inspected and cleaned annually, and let ashes cool before disposal in a metal container.
• Use a fireplace screen and keep children and pets away from hot glass.

Follow the manufacturer’s instructions and local regulations; if you smell gas or see smoke leaking, shut off the unit and call a professional.

Budget Tiers

Budget: Electric inserts and entry-level gas or small wood models. They cost less up front and are simpler to install. Mid-range: Mainstream wood and gas inserts from established makers with blowers and good glass. Premium: Large-format, high-efficiency wood inserts, direct-vent gas models with advanced flames and remotes, and pellet inserts with smart controls. Remember that installation, liner and trim kits can add substantially to the total budget tier.

Pick X If… Decision Table

Alternatives to Consider

• Freestanding stove: Offers high heat from wood, gas or pellets but needs its own venting and floor space.
• Vent-free gas logs: Restricted in some areas; follow local code and manufacturer guidance, and be aware of indoor air concerns.
• Heat pump or mini-split: A different way to cut heating bills without combustion.

Maintenance and Running Costs

Wood units need regular ash removal, glass cleaning and gasket checks. Gas units need annual service of burners, pilot and vent. Pellet units need frequent cleaning. Electric inserts need little more than a dust-free cabinet. Fuel costs vary by region and by how you source firewood; compare your local options before choosing.

Questions to Ask a Dealer or Installer

• Does the model fit my exact firebox dimensions, and which surround or trim kit closes the gap?
• What liner size and length does the maker require for my chimney height?
• What emissions certification and listed efficiency apply to this model?
• What are the clearance and hearth requirements in the manual?
• Does the quote include permits, liner, venting, gas line work and inspection?
• What warranty applies to the firebox, glass, blower and electronics?

Noise, Looks and Daily Living

Blowers add a steady hum, and pellet augers click as they feed, so listen to a working unit if possible. Glass size affects flame view: some wood inserts offer large panoramic doors, while gas models vary from traditional logs to modern linear flames. Consider how the insert fits the room, including the surround finish, any mantel above, and where the remote or thermostat will sit. Wood users should plan the route for carrying logs and a spot for the ash bucket. Gas users should note that the ignition system needs power or batteries on many models, which matters during outages, so read the manual to learn how the unit behaves without power.

Seasonal Routine

Before heating season, have the chimney and liner inspected, test alarms, and clean the glass and burners. During use, keep a small supply of dry fuel indoors only at a safe distance from the unit. At the end of the season, clean out ash, check gaskets, and close dampers as the manual specifies. These steps help preserve efficiency and reduce the chance of a chimney fire or gas-related fault.

Fuel Availability and Local Rules

Before you commit, confirm that your fuel is easy to obtain. Seasoned firewood needs months of drying and space to stack, pellets need a dry store, and gas needs an available line or a propane tank. Some municipalities limit wood burning on poor-air days or require particular emissions certifications, and condominium or rental rules may forbid alterations altogether. Contact your local building department and your insurer early, because both may require documentation of the installation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can any fireplace take an insert?

Many masonry fireplaces can, but the firebox size, chimney condition and clearances must suit the model. A certified inspector should confirm before you buy, and prefabricated fireplaces may accept only listed inserts.

Do I need a chimney liner?

Wood and many gas inserts require a stainless-steel liner connecting the unit to the chimney top. Your manual and local code define the requirement, so ask your installer.

Are fireplace inserts more efficient than open fireplaces?

Makers report that closed-combustion inserts are considerably more efficient than open hearths, because they control airflow and direct heat into the room. Actual results depend on installation, fuel and operation.

Can I install an insert myself?

Electric inserts are often plug-in, but wood, gas and pellet inserts involve venting, gas lines or clearances that affect fire and carbon monoxide safety. Hire a certified installer and follow permit rules.

Do I need a carbon monoxide alarm?

Yes, whenever you burn fuel indoors. Install alarms on each level and near sleeping areas, test them monthly and replace them per the maker’s schedule.

How often should I clean the chimney?

Industry guidance is commonly an annual inspection, with cleaning as needed. Wood-burning households that burn frequently may need more frequent attention, so ask a certified sweep.